gitwtfhub

wtf is submissions?

rougier/submissions — explained in plain English

Analysis updated 2026-07-18 · repo last pushed 2020-01-07

Audience · researcherComplexity · 2/5DormantSetup · moderate

TL;DR

The submission repository for ReScience C, a journal where researchers publish reproductions of published computational studies and reports on reproducibility problems.

Mindmap

mindmap
  root((repo))
    What it does
      Journal submissions repo
      Accepts replications
      Accepts letters
    Tech stack
      YAML metadata
      PDF template
      GitHub issues
    Use cases
      Publish a reproduction
      Report reproducibility issues
      Validate published methods
    Audience
      Researchers
      PhD students
      Industry engineers
    Process
      Prepare PDF and YAML
      Suggest editors reviewers
      Open a GitHub issue

Code map

Detail Auto

An interactive map of this repo's files and how they connect — its source is parsed live in your browser. Click Visualize to build it.

filefunction / class

Why would anyone build with this?

REASON 1

Submit a replication of a published computational study's results using your own code.

REASON 2

Publish a letter describing a reproducibility problem found in an existing computational paper.

REASON 3

Validate whether a published paper's academic code actually works in practice.

What's in the stack?

YAMLLaTeX

How it stacks up

rougier/submissions0verflowme/alarm-clock0verflowme/seclists
LanguageCSS
Last pushed2020-01-072022-10-032020-05-03
MaintenanceDormantDormantDormant
Setup difficultymoderateeasyeasy
Complexity2/52/51/5
Audienceresearchervibe coderops devops

Figures from each repo's GitHub metadata at analysis time.

How do you spin it up?

Difficulty · moderate Time to first run · 1h+

Requires preparing a PDF using their template plus YAML metadata before opening a submission issue.

Wtf does this do

ReScience C is a journal focused on reproducibility in computational science. This repository is where people submit their work to be published there. The journal accepts two types of submissions: replications (where someone reproduces an existing published study's results, often using their own code) and letters (short pieces discussing reproducibility problems or issues in computational research). Think of it like a peer-reviewed forum for saying "I tried to recreate this published result" or "I found a problem with how this computation was done." To submit, you need to gather a few things: a PDF of your article (following their template), metadata about your submission in YAML format (a simple structured text format), your code, and optionally your data. You also have the option to suggest specific editors or reviewers from their board. Once you have these ready, you create a new issue in this GitHub repository and follow the prompts. The real value here is for researchers and developers who care about whether science actually works. If you've spent time recreating someone else's computational work and want to publish that effort, or if you've discovered that a published paper has reproducibility issues, this is the venue for it. Academic journals traditionally only publish novel findings, so work that verifies or challenges existing results often goes unpublished, ReScience C changes that. It's useful for anyone from PhD students validating established methods to industry engineers checking whether academic code actually works in practice.

Yoink these prompts

Prompt 1
Walk me through preparing a PDF and YAML metadata file to submit a replication to ReScience C.
Prompt 2
Help me write a letter describing a reproducibility issue I found in a published computational study.
Prompt 3
Explain how to open a GitHub issue in this repo to submit my reproduction work to ReScience C.
Prompt 4
Show me the required format for the YAML metadata file used in ReScience C submissions.

Frequently asked questions

wtf is submissions?

The submission repository for ReScience C, a journal where researchers publish reproductions of published computational studies and reports on reproducibility problems.

Is submissions actively maintained?

Dormant — no commits in 2+ years (last push 2020-01-07).

How hard is submissions to set up?

Setup difficulty is rated moderate, with roughly 1h+ to a first successful run.

Who is submissions for?

Mainly researcher.

View the repo → Decode another repo

This repo across BitVibe Labs

Don't trust strangers blindly. Verify against the repo.